Friday, October 31, 2008

14 Favorite Political Tunes #11

public enemy - by the time i get to arizona

Thursday, October 30, 2008

14 Favorite Political Tunes #10

pearl jam do the evolution

lol

Photobucket

Uncertainty and polls

It was Christmas of 2006. My family was gathered in my Aunt’s family room after the usual Christmas dinner. The subject of conversation turned to politics which as usual, got me all excited. Being a partisan Democrat I was still elated by the results of the 2006 Congressional elections. After talking about the Democratic Takeover a friend of the family asked “So are you excited about seeing Hilary and Rudy Giuliani go at each other in 2008?” I hesitated and then expressed some reservations about Giuliani’s chances in a Republican Primary; his stances on social issues, a possible inability to resonate culturally with the republican base and his relatively small experience campaigning on a national stage were all things I cited. My Uncle seemed surprised by my analysis and mentioned that the polls he had read seemed to indicate that a Rudy/Hilary match up was likely, if not inevitable. Although my instincts seem rather prescient in hindsight its easy to see why my Uncle, like many others, had those expectations.

In an age where Americans are getting the information they want easier, quicker and more conveniently than ever the result of a Presidential election certainly goes against the grain. Its hard to even remember when this presidential campaign started, Democratic front-runner Hilary Clinton officially announced her bid on January 22nd 2007 (http://www.cnn.com/2007/POLITICS/01/20/clinton.announcement/index.html), McCain on the March 1st edition of the David Letterman show (http://www.cnn.com/2007/POLITICS/02/28/mccain.running/index.html), and Barck Obama on February 10th, 2007 (http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/americas/6349081.stm). The speculation, of course, started much earlier. I should mention that in the last national Newsweek Poll released on October 24th 2008 already contains some data on the 2012 Republican Primary with Mitt Romney leading the pack with 35% of registered Republicans, Mike Huckabee with 26% and Sarah Palin with 10% (http://www.newsweek.com/id/165570). Are we now destined for an Obama/Romney matchup in 2012?
Hardly. First of all, Obama hasn’t been elected to his first term yet. Secondly, the people conducting this poll for Newsweek presented respondents with a series of options. We don’t know if the candidates who were presented as options will even be running, yet alone if they’ll be politically viable. Furthermore, figures can suddenly appear on the national stage; just ask Barack Obama. Its easy to imagine someone like David Petraus having a significant effect on this poll were he listed as an option. And what about the voters of Iowa and New Hampshire? Someone like Tim Pawlenty may be able to connect with Iowa caucus goers more efficiently than Mitt Romney, much like Mike Huckabee connected with Iowa Republicans last January. Barack Obama certainly looked like the frontrunner of the Democratic contest after winning the Iowa caucus.

I think its important to note that although polls can be useful in terms of identifying trends, they’re hardly a flawless predictor of future events. That being said, I still find myself spending hours of my personal time reading polls. There is a dizzying array of polls on this election. I follow eight national tracking polls, one tracking poll that covers Pennsylvania and several state polls. I check three websites daily that assemble, weight and average statewide and national polls. I read crosstabs, compare the newest polls with other polls, check sample sizes, party identification, the record of the group conducting the poll and the pollsters own analysis of their work. I’ve began to wonder though, as interesting as the daily “horse race” is - are the polls I’m reading really giving me a greater ability to predict the results of this election? In an effort to quell that concern, I looked back at the accuracy of polls on past elections and found that process an insightful one.

One historical trend I found is of great relevance to the 2008 election. Although Gallup’s final pre-election polls aren’t always accurate at predicting the popular vote totals there have only been three occasions since 1980 where whoever was ahead in the pre-election poll three weeks prior to the election did not win the popular vote. The first of those occasions occurred in 1980 when Carter led Reagan by three points the third week of October. Reagan ended up winning the popular vote in that election by nearly 10 points. Its important to note though that the only presidential debate in 1980 occurred on October 28th and was largely regarded as a turning point in that campaign. The other incidents happened in 2000 and 2004 where Gallup had both sets of candidates tied in mid-October, Gore won the popular vote by .5% and Bush by 2.4% respectively. I should mention that Barack Obama was head by 7 in a Gallup poll taken three week prior to this election. In every election aside from 1980 with a clear frontrunner three weeks prior to the election (84, 88, 92, 96) Gallup accurately predicted the winner of the popular vote. In an issue of Public Opinion Quarterly Dr. Michael W. Traugott concluded that “In the end, the final estimates of the pre-election polls, the bread and butter of the polling industry, were very good at suggesting it would be a close race, with Bush the likely winner. In historical perspective, the overall performance was above average for the period since 1956.” (http://poq.oxfordjournals.org/cgi/content/full/69/5/642)

One way analysts try to predict the results of a presidential election is by assembling polls of individual states in an effort to determine a likely winner of the electoral college. The website http://www.electoral-vote.com correctly predicted the winner of the Electoral College on their last prediction on November 3rd. In 2004 Zogby International infamously predicted that John Kerry would win the Electoral College by over 300 electoral votes (http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/1297588/posts). In 2000 ABC News, The Associated Press, CNN, Fox News, NBC News, The Orvetti Report, President Elect, the President Elect computer, Portrait of America, and the Washington Times all correctly predicted the winner of the Electoral College although none of these organizations predicted the actual electoral vote total. The website FiveThirtyEight.com has become popular in this election cycle partly due to their system of analysis out performing other analyst’s predictions of several contests in the 2008 Democratic Primary. The site is run by Nate Silver who compiles polling data using methodology similar to baseball sabermetrics. Silver currently predicts Barck Obama to win the Electoral College with over 300 votes.

The Historic nature of Barack Obama’s candidacy has some analysts wondering if Barack Obama might underperform expectations set by polls due to racial motivations of voters who are afraid to disclose their true preference. This phenomenon is commonly referred to as the “Bradley Effect” named after California gubernatorial candidate Tom Bradley who underperformed pre-election polls in 1982. Interestingly enough Bradley’s performance may have had less to do with race and more to do with polls of the contest consistently being within the margin of error and a larger push for elderly Californians to vote absentee leading Republican leaning voters to be under-sampled in polls (http://www.realclearpolitics.com/articles/2008/10/the_bradley_effect_selective_m.html). A new analysis done by Harvard Post-Doctoral Fellow Daniel J. Hopkins using new data from 133 gubernatorial and Senate elections from 1989 to 2006 found that “before 1996, the median gap (underperformance) for black candidates was 3.1 percentage points, while for subsequent years it was -0.3 percentage points.” Hopkins also argued that part of the “Bradley” or “Wilder” effect (referring to Virginian Douglas Wilder the first African American governor in America) may be related to individual candidates status’ as a front runner which may also lead to favorable polling inaccuracies. After doing a survey of the results 31 contests from the 2008 Democratic Primary FiveThirtyEight.com’s Nate Silver concluded that Barack Obama overperformed expectations set by polls in 19 States including states with higher percentages of white voters like Iowa, Wisconsin and Oregon (http://www.fivethirtyeight.com/2008/08/persistent-myth-of-bradley-effect.html). A Presidential Election is certainly different than a Democratic Presidential Primary though, so its hard to tell what effect racially motivated voters will have on the final results.

Another difficulty in presidential polling is determining which voters will actually show up to the polls. Gallup has used whats called a “Likely Voter Model” with mixed results, most infamously in 2000 where on October 24th Gallup had Gore ahead of Bush by 1 point and three days later they had Bush ahead by 13 points. This cycle Gallup has a “Traditional Likely Voter Model” meant to mirror the 2004 electorate and an “Expanded Likely Voter Model” that estimates higher turnout by young Americans and minorities. Under this “Traditional” model a voter can be registered and say they’re determined to vote and still be excluded from the model if they didn’t vote in 2004. There has also been some recent concern that pollsters are undersampling young Democratic leaning voters because of a prevalence of cell phone only households among those under 30. Pollster Ann Selzer estimates that as many as 50% of voters under 30 rely on cell phone service (Selzer & Co).
Polling has been especially erratic this election cycle, a current survey of national polls has Obama’s margin of victory as low as 3 points (Rasmussen Reports) and as high as 14 points (Pew Research Center). There is a lot of anecdotal evidence to add to all of this uncertainty. On August 5th the New York Times reported that reported that “since 2005, Democrats have gained some 214,000 voters in the 26 states with available registration data while Republican registration has dropped by more than 1.4 million”. More than 540,000 votes have already been cast in Georgia and black voters have made up a disproportionately high percentage of those votes, accounting for 37 percent of Georgia's early votes when 29 percent of the state's 5.6 million registered voters are African American (Associated Press), this may be some indication of unprecedented turnout among African Americans. Oregon’s Vote By Mail system provides an interesting study for voter turnout. The amount of ballots cast prior to October 29th 2008 represent a 19% decline in turnout compared to the ballots cast before October 29th 2004. Interestingly enough is to compare the difference between 2008 and 2004 in specific counties. In traditionally Democratic counties like Lane, Benton and Multnomah County the decline in turnout is between 12 and 16%. In Republican leaning counties like Klamath, Douglas and Linn County the decline in turnout varies from 16% to a staggering 41.5% (http://www.sos.state.or.us/elections/). This will certainly have some impact on races in Oregon, but again, if this trend is some indicator of a national trend in GOP enthusiasm and manifests itself in other states it could lead to some very interesting results on November 4th. The reason why I bring up all this anecdotal evidence is to illustrate the point that there are important trends that may not manifest themselves in polling. If certain groups are undersampled or oversampled then pollsters “Likely Voter Models” will be useless.

That being said I do feel that following polls, in addition to being a fun hobby, is a valuable practice. This is especially true when compared to the alternative of not following polls. Knowing that a certain candidate is ahead or behind can provide a meaningful context in which to view important events in a presidential campaign. If a candidate does something drastic like running a negative ad or naming an unknown Governor of Alaska as his Vice Presidential Candidate knowing that they’re behind in the polls may give you some insight into their decision making process. If you can’t decide between making a donation to a local political campaign or a national one it might be helpful to know candidates viability. Polls are great at providing some foresight as to who will decide the future of our communities and ultimately our country. By many traditional metrics it looks likely that Barack Obama will be the first African American president of the United States but things are far from certain. Unprecedented events occur on a regular basis and that’s what keeps me interested in politics (and checking dozens of polls everyday).

Wednesday, October 29, 2008

That informercial

Heres my initial thoughts:

1. Could that have been anymore folksy?

2. Generationaly this will fall flat among Millenial and Gen X voters, Several important groups though: low information voters, white boomer women, seniors I think this may really resonate.

3. We really won't know how successful this was until Friday or Saturday at the earliest in terms of the trackers. I'm not sure when the Neilson ratings will be out, but judging by the demos they'll release we'll be able to get a good picture of who exactly saw this thing.

Big Oregon Poll News

From the trib:

By Steve Law

The Portland Tribune, Oct 28, 2008, Updated 4.5 hours ago

Democratic state Sens. Kate Brown and Ben Westlund are in solid position to become Oregon’s next secretary of state and state treasurer, according to a new poll for the Portland Tribune and Fox 12.

Brown, a Portland Democrat, leads Springfield Republican Rick Dancer, a former television journalist, 38 percent to 32 percent in the secretary of state’s race, according to a new poll by Portland polling firm Davis, Hibbitts & Midghall Inc. Portland software engineer Seth Woolley, running on the Pacific Green Party ticket, had 4 percent in the poll, while 25 percent were undecided.

Davis, Hibbitts & Midghall Inc. polled 500 registered voters around the state from Oct. 23 through Oct. 25. The poll has a margin of error of plus or minus 4.4 percent.

Six weeks earlier, a Tribune/Fox 12 poll by the same firm found Brown led Dancer 33 percent to 25 percent, with 38 percent undecided.

Westlund, a Bend-area Democrat, leads Lake Oswego Republican Allen Alley by 39 percent to 28 percent in the treasurer’s race, the new poll showed. Constitution Party candidate Michael Marsh, a McDonald’s maintenance worker from Salem, is favored by 3 percent of voters, while 29 percent remain undecided, according to the poll.

A Tribune/News 12 poll by the same firm six weeks ago found Westlund led Alley 31 percent to 20 percent, with 45 percent undecided.

There still are a high number of undecided voters, giving Dancer and Alley a shot at winning, said Tim Hibbitts, who conducted the poll for Davis, Hibbitts & Midghall. But neither has narrowed the gap significantly since the last survey six weeks ago, and many Oregonians have already cast their ballots.

“Nobody’s really gained. What’s happened is the undecideds have dropped,” Hibbitts said.

If that pattern continues, “it benefits the Democrats,” he said. “It would be an upset for either Republican to win.”
New voters could swamp GOP

Secretary of State Bill Bradbury and Oregon Treasurer Randall Edwards are stepping down after serving two terms. Neither is allowed to run again because of term limits. Bradbury is pondering a run for governor in 2010, while Edwards is exploring his career options.

Kate Brown, who has served in the Legislature since 1991, was Senate majority leader until she relinquished that position last year to run for secretary of state. A lawyer by training, she has worked in family law.

This is Dancer’s first run for elective office after a long television news career in Eugene.

Dancer entered the race late, while Brown has been campaigning since the 2007 legislative session ended. She has raised $1.6 million since August 2007, much of it spent on a competitive primary against fellow state Senators Rick Metsger and Vicki Walker. Dancer has raised $370,521.

Westlund gained statewide name recognition in 2006, when he switched from the Republican Party to run for governor as an independent. He later pulled out of the race and switched to the Democratic Party.

Westlund made a fortune in the bull-breeding business, and also co-owned a kitty litter manufacturing company. He works as a health care consultant.

Alley left his post as Gov. Ted Kulongoski’s deputy chief of staff to enter the race. He is a former venture capitalist, and former executive at two local technology companies. He was president of Pixelworks Inc. and vice president of InFocus Corp.

Alley is relatively new to politics but his business credentials helped land several newspaper endorsements. Alley appeared to be picking up momentum with the endorsements, which can prove helpful in a race where voters know little about the candidates or the office.

But Alley entered the race late, after initially announcing he wouldn’t run. Westlund has been actively campaigning since the 2007 legislative session ended, and has raised $754,977. Alley started collecting money in March of this year, and has raised $463,993.

The souring economy and President George W. Bush’s lackluster support among voters makes Hibbitts and most other political analysts doubtful of any Republican gains in Oregon this year. The one exception is Westlund’s state Senate seat. He initially won election as a Republican, not a Democrat, so the GOP has a good shot at reclaiming the seat.

Oregon Democrats’ success in enlisting new voters makes it even tougher for Republicans. Oregon Democrats added 158,321 registered voters from January through September, an increase of 20.9 percent. Republicans added only 979 registered voters during that period, an increase of 1.4 percent.

Democrats have a 43.3 percent to 32.5 percent voter-registration advantage over Republicans statewide, as of Sept. 30. At the end of 2007, Democrats led Republicans 38.8 percent to 35.2 percent among registered voters.

stevelaw@portlandtribune.com

14 Favorite Political Tunes #9

#9 Bruce Springsteen - American Skin



41 shots....
and we'll take that ride
'cross this bloody river
to the other side
41 shots... cut through the night
You're kneeling over his body in the vestibule
Praying for his life

Is it a gun, is it a knife
Is it a wallet, this is your life
It ain't no secret
It ain't no secret
No secret my friend
You can get killed just for living
In your American skin

41 shots
Lena gets her son ready for school
She says "on these streets, Charles
You've got to understand the rules
If an officer stops you
Promise you'll always be polite,
that you'll never ever run away
Promise Mama you'll keep your hands in sight"

Is it a gun, is it a knife
Is it a wallet, this is your life
It ain't no secret
It ain't no secret
No secret my friend
You can get killed just for living
In your American skin

Is it a gun, is it a knife
Is it in your heart, is it in your eyes
It ain't no secret

41 shots... and we'll take that ride
'Cross this bloody river
To the other side
41 shots... got my boots caked in this mud
We're baptized in these waters and in each other's blood

Is it a gun, is it a knife
Is it a wallet, this is your life
It ain't no secret
It ain't no secret
No secret my friend
You can get killed just for living
In your American skin